To some market watchers, the recent decline in the CBOE Volatility Index (.VIX) is a sign of investor optimism, bullishness and even complacency. After all, VIX is the market’s “fear gauge†and a measure of investor sentiment. Friday, the index closed at 23.09 and its lowest levels in almost 10 months. It is well below the extremes near 100 seen in the fall of 2008. So, are the new lows from the volatility index cause for concern? Is there too much bullishness and complacency in the equity market today?
While extreme readings from the VIX often signal overbought or oversold market conditions, the latest decline also reflects a change in actual volatility. The CBOE Volatility Index tracks the expected volatility priced into S&P 500 Index (.SPX) options and it is not only a gauge of sentiment. It also reflects the daily price swings of the S&P 500. Today, for example, the 20-day historical volatility (based on closing prices over the past 20 days) of the S&P 500 is only 22 percent–which is below the recent readings of the VIX and also well below the extremes in the mid-80s seen at the peak of the market debacle of 2008.
Since VIX is a measure of volatility, when it reaches extremes, it sometimes makes sense to look at other sentiment indicators to determine if sentiment is really overly bullish or bearish. Right now, for example, Investors Intelligence reports that 36.7 percent of those surveyed are bullish and 35.6 percent are bearish. Meanwhile, the American Association of Individual Investors reports that only 37.6 percent of those surveyed are bullish and 42.4 percent are bearish. These two sentiment surveys aren’t consistent with extreme bullishness.
The reliable International Securities Exchange Sentiment Index [ISEE] hasn’t produced any extreme readings either. ISEE is a unique index created by the International Securities Exchange. It tracks daily call buying divided by put buying (X100) for all trading on the ISE (sales are ignored). During periods of extreme optimism, when investors are leaning heavily on the call side of the trade, ISEE will spike above 200. The chart below, available on iseoptions.com, shows that the last meaningful spike in the index was on March 9. The ten-day average (not on the chart) is 118 and not consistent with over zealousness or overbought market conditions.

ISEE (source: iseoptions.com)
Fund flows are not consistent with extreme bullishness. According to AMG Data, investors added $5.1 billion to stock funds during the month of June and a whopping $38.6 billion during the second quarter. The pace has slowed over the past few weeks: $673 million outflows in the first week of July, followed by $1.1 billion of outflows, and then $193 million in inflows last week. Mutual fund investors are not bullish, but have been net sellers in July (until last week.)
But do all these “sentiment indicators” really matter???
After the market crash of 2008, investor confidence had been lost. Pessimism reached an extreme and, only once some confidence had been restored, could the equity market begin to move higher. Beginning in March 2009, falling levels of negativity and increasing optimism turned into a self-feeding cycle that has now sent the S&P 500 up almost 45 percent since spring 2009 lows. That powerful trend remains intact and could continue until sentiment has reached the other extreme–of bullishness and optimism. Judging by the sentiment surveys, ISEE and fund flows, investor sentiment has not yet reached the bullish extreme.
Importantly, the historically volatile months of September and October are fast approaching and, as Steven Sears points out in the latest Barron’s Striking Price. “traders expect Volatility to come back tanned, rested and ready to shake up the stock market this fall.†If so, the few weeks ahead could offer an opportunity to buy cheaper options–as VIX and implied volatility sit near 9-month lows–and create interesting risk-reward trades like strangles, ratio backspreads, and selective put buying on sectors or stocks that are most vulnerable should volatility spike in the fall 2009. Check the blog for unusual bearish activity and track the “smart money†trades to find opportunities. Get more frequent updates and ideas by subscribing to WhatsTrading.com Premium.